When I was a first-time mom, I had the most difficult time trying to find basket stuffers for my baby’s first Easter! I wandered around Target with my baby for way longer than she would have preferred trying to see if she got excited about anything. Well, I’m here to keep you from struggling through the same difficulties I did by providing you with a long, categorized list of Easter basket filler ideas that your baby will LOVE!
If you’d like a list with more specific recommendations and product links, feel free to check out this article!
I mean, lets be real, even the tiniest family members deserve a special basket! If you’re looking for fun, safe, and baby-friendly Easter basket ideas, here are 50 creative options that are both practical and adorable, and won’t leave you wandering the store with a bored baby trying to find the perfect gifts!
Soft and Cuddly Gifts
- Plush bunny, chick, or lamb – Because every baby needs a snuggly sidekick!
- Personalized baby blanket – Wrap them up in love (and super soft fabric) with their very own name on it.
- Crinkle toys for sensory play – Babies LOVE that satisfying crinkle sound—trust me, it’s baby magic.
- Soft fabric books – Who says bedtime stories can’t be chewable?
- Knitted or crochet rattle – Handmade, adorable, and perfect for tiny hands to shake, shake, shake!
- Taggie blanket – So many little ribbons to grab and explore. This one’s a winner!
- Lovey or comforter – A mini security blanket to be their cuddle buddy for years to come.
- Small stuffed animal with baby-safe features – Nothing beats a squishy little animal friend!
- Soft fabric stacking rings – They can’t stack yet, but they’ll sure love chewing on them!
- Plush hand puppet – Get ready for silly puppet shows at playtime!
Teething and Sensory Toys
- Silicone teething rings – The chew must go on! These are lifesavers for sore little gums.
- Wooden teething toys – Natural, non-toxic, and totally baby-approved.
- Freezable teether – Cool, soothing, and oh-so-refreshing for tiny teethers.
- Teething mittens – Because sometimes, their own hand is the best toy!
- Sensory balls – Bumpy, squishy, and oh-so-fun to grab and explore.
- Baby-safe mirrors – “Who’s that cutie?” Babies LOVE looking at themselves!
- Rattle socks – Wiggly toes + jingling sounds = endless entertainment!
- Water-filled teething toy – Chill it in the fridge and watch the relief set in.
- Spinning rattle – Shake it, spin it, giggle, repeat!
- Baby-friendly sensory board – Different textures, colors, and surprises to discover.
Books and Early Learning
- Easter-themed board book – Hop into storytime with a festive little tale!
- Indestructible books – the ones we have are prettyyyyy indestructible if i do say so myself.
- High-contrast black and white books – Perfect for little newborn developing eyes!
- Touch-and-feel books – Because textures make everything more exciting!
- Books with mirrors – Again, babies and mirrors = endless fascination.
- Sound books with buttons – Press, giggle, repeat! A great way to introduce cause and effect.
- Personalized baby name book – Because seeing their name in a story is just magical.
- Small photo album with family pictures – A mini memory book of all their favorite faces!
- Lift-the-flap board books – Surprise! The cutest game of peek-a-boo in book form.
- Classic nursery rhyme books – Because “Twinkle Twinkle” never goes out of style.
Bath Time Fun
- Rubber ducky – Bathtime isn’t complete without one (or five) of these!
- Floating bath animals – Little buddies to keep them company in the tub.
- Stacking bath cups – Pour, stack, and splash… it’s the toddler trifecta!
- Soft washcloth puppets – Bath + puppet show? Yes, please!
- Hooded towel – Nothing is cuter than a baby wrapped up as a tiny bunny.
- Waterproof bath books – Storytime doesn’t have to end at the tub!
- Bath thermometer toy – Make sure the water’s just right with a cute little floating helper.
- Non-slip bath mat with fun designs – Safety first, but make it adorable.
Mealtime Essentials
- Silicone bib with a pocket – Catching all those dropped snacks like a pro!
- Baby-safe utensils – Tiny forks and spoons for tiny hands!
- Suction bowl or plate – Because flying bowls are NOT on the Easter menu.
- Organic baby snacks (puffs, teething biscuits) – Snack time just got tastier!
- Personalized baby food jar labels – So you know exactly what’s inside those homemade meals.
- Reusable food pouches – Less mess, more yum!
- Soft baby spoons – Gentle on gums, and perfect for first bites.
- Insulated bottle holder – Keeping drinks at just the right temp.
- Fruit feeder pacifier – Let them safely nibble on fresh fruit without the worry!
Practical & Personalized Gifts
- Custom baby onesie – The cuter, the better! Bonus points for Easter puns.
- Soft baby socks – Because those tiny toes need to stay cozy! Will also please all the older ladies out there.
- Personalized pacifier clip – No more dropping binkies on the floor 50 times a day!
- Cute Easter-themed hat – Bunny ears, anyone?!
- Comfy baby clothes – Soft, stretchy, and perfect for little movers.
- Sleep sack – Because a comfy baby is a sleepy baby (fingers crossed!).
- Soft bandana bibs – Stylish AND practical (win-win!).
- Handmade crochet booties – Like tiny hugs for their feet.
- Name-engraved wooden rattle – A keepsake that’s both beautiful and functional.
Final Tips for Assembling a Baby Easter Basket
- Stick with baby-safe materials – Avoid small parts, choking hazards, and hard plastics.
- Mix fun and practical – Balance entertainment with essentials like bibs and socks.
- Go sensory – Babies love textures, sounds, and colors that engage their curiosity.
- Keep it simple – A few well-chosen items make for a perfect baby basket!
With these 50 Easter basket stuffer ideas for babies, you can now create a sweet and thoughtful Easter surprise for your baby without the hassle.
If you’d like a list with more specific recommendations and product links, feel free to check out this article!
Happy Basket Stuffing!
