Easter is right around the corner, and if you’re anything like me, you’re probably knee-deep in plastic eggs, wondering what in the world to put inside them. Or you’re at least thinking about how you’re going to stuff the bunches of plastic eggs you’ll be dealing with in the future. Sure, candy is the go-to, but let’s be real—kids get more than enough sugar as it is. Plus, if you’ve ever watched a sugar-fueled toddler bouncing off the walls, you know it’s a situation best avoided, especially on a holiday notorious for large family gatherings.
This year, I’ve made it my mission to get creative with Easter egg fillers. My kids still get a little candy, but I mix in fun surprises that keep the excitement going long after the sugar rush fades. If you’re looking for fresh ideas, you’re in the right place! Let’s dive into 100+ non-candy Easter egg fillers that your kids will love, with some age guidelines as well!
Tiny Treasures That Fit Inside Easter Eggs
Sometimes, the smallest things bring the biggest joy! Here are some mini surprises that fit perfectly inside those little plastic eggs:
- Toddlers (Ages 1-3): Finger puppets, teething toys, chunky crayons, snack-sized cereal, mini stuffed animals
- Preschoolers (Ages 3-5): Mini erasers, stickers, temporary tattoos, small stamps, bouncy balls
- Early Elementary (Ages 5-7): Miniature action figures or dolls, cute keychains, glow-in-the-dark stars, plastic animals or dinosaurs
- Older Kids (Ages 8+): Mini slinkies, tiny brain teaser puzzles, pocket-sized notebooks, trendy keychains
Artsy & Creative Surprises
For the little artists in your life, these egg stuffers encourage creativity:
- Toddlers (Ages 1-3): Chunky crayons, simple sticker sheets, water-reveal coloring sheets
- Preschoolers (Ages 3-5): Mini gel pens, small notepads, colorful stickers, costume jewelry, stick-on earrings
- Early Elementary (Ages 5-7): Mini watercolor paints, DIY scratch art sheets, fun-shaped erasers
- Older Kids (Ages 8+): Small calligraphy pens, tiny sketchbooks, travel-sized coloring kits
Interactive & Activity-Based Ideas
Want to keep your kids entertained beyond the egg hunt? Try these:
- Toddlers (Ages 1-3): Soft rubber toys, pop-it keychains, easy-to-hold puzzles
- Preschoolers (Ages 3-5): Mini LEGO sets, tiny playdough containers, glow sticks
- Early Elementary (Ages 5-7): Magnetic letters or numbers, small fidget toys, scavenger hunt clues
- Older Kids (Ages 8+): Mini Rubik’s cubes, mini card games, mini flashlights
Practical & Useful Egg Stuffers
Who says Easter egg fillers can’t be functional too?
- Toddlers (Ages 1-3): Cute band-aids (honestly, genius), mini hairbrushes, fun-shaped toothbrush covers
- Preschoolers (Ages 3-5): Hair accessories, fun shoelaces, small hand sanitizers
- Early Elementary (Ages 5-7): Mini nail polish, small notebooks, trendy keychains
- Older Kids (Ages 8+): Mini perfumes or colognes, phone grips, stylish hair clips
Snack Ideas (Healthier & Less Messy!)
If you’re looking for snack fillers that won’t send your child into a sugar coma, try these:
- Toddlers (Ages 1-3): Cheerios, yogurt melts, puffs, mini rice cakes
- Preschoolers (Ages 3-5): Goldfish crackers, mini pretzels, dried fruit pieces
- Early Elementary (Ages 5-7): Granola bites, trail mix (without nuts if needed), fruit leather
- Older Kids (Ages 8+): Protein bites, chocolate-covered nuts, chocolate covered pretzels
Easter Egg Fillers for Older Kids
Older kids may not be as excited about stickers and tiny toys, but that doesn’t mean they should be left out of the fun!
- Ages 8+: Mini nail polish, cute earrings or rings, small makeup items, gift cards, money
Themed Surprise Eggs
If your child has a favorite hobby or interest, tailor the eggs to fit their passions!
- Superhero Theme: Tiny figures, stickers, keychains, mini comics
- Dinosaur Theme: Mini dino figures, fossil stickers, tiny eggs with baby dinos
- Unicorn Theme: Mini unicorn erasers, tiny glittery bracelets, stickers
- Science Theme: Small magnifying glass, mini experiment kits, glow-in-the-dark slime
Easter Egg Coupons & Experience-Based Ideas
Want to make the fun last beyond Easter Sunday? Consider adding small paper coupons inside the eggs:
- “Movie night—your pick!”
- “Breakfast in bed”
- “One extra bedtime story”
- “Trip to the park”
- “Ice cream date with Mom/Dad”
- “You pick what’s for dinner”
These add a personal touch and give your kids something to look forward to even after the egg hunt is over! Don’t want to make them yourself? Check out these super cute printable Easter themed coupons!
Final Thoughts
Switching up Easter egg fillers beyond candy makes the holiday more exciting and even more meaningful. Kids get to enjoy a variety of fun surprises without the sugar overload, and you get to enjoy the post-Easter calm—rather than dealing with a house full of chocolate-fueled chaos.
The best part? Watching your little ones light up when they crack open an egg to find something truly unexpected. Whether you go for tiny toys, useful goodies, or experience-based surprises, the joy of the hunt remains the same. Happy Easter egg stuffing!
